Early this morning, my dear friend June asked a question on Twitter which struck me with all the bluntness of a machete to my workdesk:
RT @j_rubis Why do some older women act like schoolgirls & gang up on a younger woman? It’s creepy.
If you’re anything like me, tweets addressed to no one in particular become a self-centred exploration of past sins. Have I done something like that before? Was I conscious of what I did; did I give a whit of consideration to what I was doing to another person? Did I do it willingly and thinkingly? You awful person, you did.
And what struck me most about this particular frustrated note was the sureness I felt, that I had done this before. I can’t remember to whom or when – likely it was during my delusional tyrannical primary school years, where I was vicious and socially inept to a fault – but I just knew I had.
It was a frightening feeling.
I judge people. I don’t hide the fact that I do. One of my ‘things’ is hanging out with friends, generating parodies of social commentaries on stereotypes; I judge them knowing I can never fully know them and that I’m painting a superficial caricature of how that person appears; I know that I can in no way reach the person’s essence. However, some truths (and character traits) are self-evident. Most of the time, I keep such thoughts to myself. Every now and then I judge myself, viciously and angrily, until I can no longer look my reflection in the eye.
I come from a strong history of self-deprecation and admittance of faults, and perhaps it’s only natural that I nitpick others as well. Once upon a time, I’d have no qualms about saying them aloud and to a person’s face. Being educated in a co-ed system meant that the majority of my interactions where with other girls (statuses usually remain quo), and I learned (slowly) over the course of my schooling years that doing so was less truthful than hurtful.
Something happened which reminded me of our tendency to bully in packs, just two days ago, at my cousin’s wedding. I love my cousins, but I loathe weddings. Everyone is forced to be nice to each other and plaster on fake smiles and heavy makeup; petty hatchets resurface amid the tangled dance of courtesies, and you come back from such events learning more facts about certain people you wish you hadn’t.
My cousin’s relatives (unrelated to me) had arrived at the wedding party a little later than everyone else – a group of sisters in their mid-20’s and late-teens. They were not particular beauties, but they had symmetrical features, long dark hair, lithe young bodies and all the self-assurance of people who felt themselves pretty enough to move ahead in the world. They were known among the family to have certain airs that came with vanity – the Malay word for it is ‘gedik’, I believe. These young ladies don’t laugh and talk, but giggle and titter instead, and they don’t walk but sway, their hips moving in an exaggerated expression of perceived femininity. They were everything almost every man wants – they displayed a successful vision of the culturally ideal young woman.
My own cousins and nieces, all in their early teens and only just burgeoning into that probing consciousness of womanhood we all go through, looked on admiringly. They wanted to know who the sisters were, and what they did and where they went to school and how old they were. Oh, look how lovely their hair shone in the midday sun. So tall, and so pretty.
My writing is self-evident of my impression of these sisters. I know that one of them is smart and driven, if a little giggly. I know that all of them are kind, friendly and respectful. I know that I barely know them at all, except for family functions such as these, where we barely interacted because I have scant patience for topics and interests I don’t share. (I usually ended up in a fierce discussion with the old uncles (about politics or other stuff only they talk about at weddings) until my mother would drag me away.)
But as I answered my young cousins and nieces’ questions about these sisters as best I could, I felt wary. I wondered if it was my jealousy of their looks and confidence. I wondered if it was dread at knowing that my young girls were picking up these conformist notions of beauty, that they had to dress and primp a certain way to catch a man’s eye. They are young still, and I would rather they be themselves than chase an ideal look or an age they’re not. I suddenly felt conscious of my own dress and makeup; I could feel the uneven eyeliner on the corner of my eyelid weigh down on me. It unnerved me that I, too, shared my cousins’ knowledge that this was what women were told they should look like, that this was how women are meant to behave and talk. The sisters were everything I am not.
Still, I kept these thoughts to myself. I did not dismiss aloud the sisters’ obvious efforts at beauty, nor their precariously high heels, nor their obvious awareness of being observed and admired. My cousins and nieces are young and impressionable, but they still had time to form their own ideas. I would rather they admire these women than hate on them for things we did not even know for certain. I understood my own jealousy and feelings of inadequacy, but these young girls must learn to form opinions and impressions of people, especially other women, on their own. Our sex does get a lot of flak for being quick to gang up on others, especially if they are perceived to be a threat, no matter how vague. While I do not believe it is a means of bullying exclusive to females, women are perhaps more cruel when they resort to this, because we know what truly gets to a girl, and we attack with the precision and cruelty of assassins. We may not take away life, but we take away a girl’s security, sense of self and confidence, and how is that any better?
I believe that in some form or manner, I may have done this style of bullying before. I may still be guilty of it now. Sometimes it’s easy to fall into a pack and start picking each other’s flaws; I’ve both experienced and seen it being done in an actual playground, as a child. While I try to be fair about my words (I am as critical of men as I am of women), I know how tempting it is to narc on someone, as part of a group. At an age where young women are still figuring themselves out and trying to find their space in the world, I don’t wish my own pessimism to mar the way my cousins and nieces see other girls, hypocritical though it may be. I want them to find in other women confidants, kindred spirits, role models, and inspiration for when times get tough. I want to share my own mistakes as a teenage girl so they won’t make the very same.
A couple of hours after the sisters arrived, I overheard the eldest in conversation with my younger brother, as they compared internships at law firms. She flipped her long, dark mane of hair over one shoulder as she discussed spiritedly with my brother the pros and cons of working in a small firm. It reminded me that while I judge people at will, it is always important to remember that I will be pleasantly surprised by the very same people. I smiled to myself, moving past them quickly, not wishing to intrude, and was grateful that I held my tongue. We judge books by their covers, but we treasure them based on their contents.